CHEMICAL HYPERSENSITIVITY AND THE ALLERGIC RESPONSE
HTTP://WWW.AEHF.COM/ARTICLES/ARTICLE36.HTML
BY WILLIAM J. REA, M.D.
REPRINTED FROM THE EAR, NOSE, AND THROAT JOURNAL, VOL 67, NO 1, JANUARY 1988.
PUBLISHED BY LITTLE, BROWN AND COMPANY, BOSTON, MA. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO
PART OF THIS REPRINT MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY ELECTRONIC OR
MECHANICAL MEANS, INCLUDING INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEMS, WITHOUT THE
PUBLISHER€™S CONSENT.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR . . . . WILLIAM J. REA, MD, FACS, FACA, IS DIRECTOR OF THE
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH CENTER€”DALLAS, AND HE IS A PRACTICING CARDIOVASCULAR
SURGEON IN DALLAS, TX.
THE WIDESPREAD CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION OF THE EARTH€™S AIR, FOOD, AND WATER
WITH ITS EFFECTS ON VARIOUS BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS HAS BEEN DESCRIBED IN NEARLY 5,000
SCIENTIFIC ARTICLES. AT PRESENT, CHEMICAL SENSITIVITY CAN BE DEFINED AS AN
ADVERSE REACTION TO AMBIENT LEVELS OF TOXIC CHEMICALS, WHICH ARE GENERALLY
ACCEPTED AS BEING "SUBTOXIC," IN ENVIRONMENTAL AIR (HOME AND PUBLIC BUILDINGS),
FOOD, AND WATER.1 THE MANIFESTATION OF ADVERSE REACTIONS DEPENDS ON THE TISSUES
OR ORGANS INVOLVED, THE CHEMICAL AND PHARMACOLOGIC NATURE OF THE SUBSTANCES
INVOLVED, THE INDIVIDUAL SUSCEPTIBILITY OF THE EXPOSED PERSON (NUTRITIONAL STATE,
GENETIC MAKE-UP, AND TOXIC LOAD AT THE TIME OF EXPOSURE), THE LENGTH OF TIME,
AMOUNT, AND VARIETY OF OTHER BODY STRESSORS (TOTAL LOAD), AND THE POSSIBLE
SYNERGISM AMONG THESE AT THE TIME OF REACTION.
IT IS OFTEN DIFFICULT, AND AT TIMES IMPOSSIBLE, TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN
ALLERGIC AND TOXIC RESPONSES, AND CHEMICAL SENSITIVITIES MAY ENCOMPASS BOTH.
CHEMICAL ALLERGIES INVOLVE AN IGE OR IGG RESPONSE, AND ARE A SMALL BUT SIGNIFICANT
PART OF THE OVERALL SPECTRUM OF CHEMICAL SENSITIVITY. AN EXAMPLE IS THE
IGE-MEDIATED TOLUENE DIISOCYANATE ANTIGEN-ANTIBODY REACTION. ANOTHER TYPE HAS BEEN
FOUND IN SURVIVORS OF ACUTE POISONING WHO DEVELOP CHEMICAL SENSITIVITY, BUT IS
USUALLY NOT IGE- OR IGG-MEDIATED. IN TWO LARGE INCIDENCES€”THE GASSING OF TROOPS
DURING WORLD WAR I AND THE CYANIDE ACCIDENT IN BHOPAL, INDIA€”EXPOSED PERSONS
HAVE DEVELOPED CHEMICAL SENSITIVITIES. IN CONTRAST, THE ETIOLOGY OF THOSE WHO
HAVE BECOME CHEMICALLY SENSITIVE FOLLOWING LONG-TERM SUBACUTE TOXIC EXPOSURES
IS OFTEN DIFFICULT TO DISCERN. A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF PERSONS ARE INVOLVED,
PERHAPS AS MUCH AS 20% OF THE POPULATION. THE CHEMICALLY SENSITIVE PERSON MAY
DEVELOP REACTIONS QUITE SUDDENLY OR GRADUALLY OVER A PERIOD OF YEARS. THE
CONCENTRATION OF CHEMICALS NEEDED TO TRIGGER A RESPONSE DIMINISHES AND REACTION TO A
MINIMAL AMOUNT OF TOXIC CHEMICAL MAY BE POSSIBLE. THIS PROGRESSION IS
PROBABLY RELATED TO AN OVERLOAD OF THE ENZYME DETOXIFICATION SYSTEMS. CHEMICAL
SENSITIVITY IS USUALLY MANIFESTED IN ONE MAIN ORGAN WITH SECONDARY EFFECTS IN
OTHERS, AND SYMPTOMS ARE USUALLY MULTIPLE. THE END-ORGAN RESPONSES ARE OFTEN IN THE
SMOOTH MUSCLES OF NEURO-CARDIOVASCULAR, GASTROINTESTINAL, UROGENITAL, AND
RESPIRATORY SYSTEMS, AS WELL AS THE SKIN, BUT ANY ORGAN MAY BE INVOLVED.
MUCH OF THE CONTROVERSY ABOUT CHEMICAL SENSITIVITY STEMS FROM THE CLINICIAN€™S
INABILITY TO RECOGNIZE THE OCCURRENCE OF ENVIRONMENTAL OVERLOAD WITH
SUBSEQUENT APPLICATION OF APPROPRIATE CLINICAL DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT TO THE
INDIVIDUAL PATIENT.
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
THE TOTAL BODY LOAD IS THE TOTAL OF ALL INCITANTS TO WHICH THE BODY HAS TO
RESPOND TO MAINTAIN HOMEOSTASIS.1 POLLUTANTS MAY BE BIOLOGICAL (POLLENS, DUSTS,
MOLDS, VIRUSES, BACTERIAS), CHEMICAL (ORGANIC OR INORGANIC), OR PHYSICAL
(HEAT, COLD, ELECTROMAGNETIC RADIATION, LIGHT, RADON, AND POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE
IONS). TO PREVENT DISEASE, THE BODY MUST MANAGE THIS BURDEN THROUGH USE OR
ELIMINATION. IF THE LOAD IS EXCESSIVE, SYMPTOMS MAY OCCUR AS A RESPONSE TO
DISTURBANCE OF THE BODY€™S IMMUNE AND ENZYME DETOXIFICATION SYSTEMS.1
ACUTE TOXILOGIC TOLERANCE (MASKING, ADAPTATION) IS A CHANGE IN THE
HOMEOSTASIS (STEADY RATE) INDUCED BY THE INTERNAL OR EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT, WITH
ACCOMMODATION OF BODY FUNCTION ADJUSTING TO A NEW SET POINT.2 THIS ADAPTATION OR
MASKING IS AN ACUTE SURVIVAL MECHANISMS IN WHICH THE PERSON APPARENTLY ADJUSTS TO A
CONSTANT ACUTE TOXIC EXPOSURE TO SURVIVE INITIALLY BUT THEN LATER PAYS THE
PRICE WITH A LONG-TERM DECREASE IN EFFICIENT FUNCTIONING AND, PERHAPS,
LONGEVITY. BECAUSE OF THIS PHENOMENON, THE TOTAL BODY LOAD MAY INCREASE WITHOUT THE
PERSON KNOWING. EVEN THOUGH NO CORRELATED SYMPTOMS ARE APPARENT, REPEATED
EXPOSURES CONTINUE TO DAMAGE THE IMMUNE AND ENZYME DETOXIFICATION SYSTEMS, AND THE
EVENTUAL RESULT IS END-ORGAN FAILURE. AVOIDANCE OF THE OFFENDING SUBSTANCE FOR
FOUR DAYS MAY UNMASK ASSOCIATED SYMPTOMS. INITIAL WITHDRAWAL SYMPTOMS MAY EVEN
OCCUR. HOWEVER, SUBSEQUENT RE-EXPOSURE WILL PRODUCE AN IMMEDIATE AND CLEARLY
DEFINABLE REACTION BECAUSE CAUSE AND EFFECT ARE EASILY DISTINGUISHED.
WHEN EXPOSED TO A TOXIC SUBSTANCE, THE BODY INITIALLY DEVELOPS A BIPOLAR
RESPONSE, WITH A STIMULATORY PHASE FOLLOWED BY A DEPRESSIVE PHASE.3 INDUCTION OF
THE DETOXIFICATION SYSTEMS OCCURS. IF THE INCITANT IS VIRULENT, BIOCHEMICALLY
ACTIVE, OR OF SUBSTANTIAL VOLUME OR DURATION, THE DETOXIFICATION SYSTEMS MAY BE
DEPLETED (DEPRESSED) BY OVERSTIMULATION. AT THE SAME TIME, A PERSON MAY
PERCEIVE A STIMULATORY REACTION IN THE BRAIN AND INITIALLY FEEL THAT THE INCITING
SUBSTANCE IS NOT HARMFUL BUT ACTUALLY PLEASURABLE. THEREFORE, THE PERSON MAY
CONTINUE TO SUBJECT HIM OR HERSELF TO MORE EXPOSURES; WITH TIME (MINUTES TO
YEARS), HOWEVER, THE BODY€™S DEFENSES CAN BREAK DOWN AND DEPRESSION-EXHAUSTION
SYMPTOMS DEVELOP. THIS STIMULATION AND THE RESULTANT RESPONSE HAS BEEN OBSERVED
WITH MANY POLLUTANT EXPOSURES, INCLUDING OZONE.
BIOCHEMICAL INDIVIDUALITY ACCOUNTS FOR INDIVIDUAL SUSCEPTIBILITY. EACH PERSON
HAS DIFFERING QUANTITIES OF CARBOHYDRATES, FATS, PROTEINS, ENZYMES, VITAMINS,
MINERALS, AND IMMUNE PARAMETERS WITH WHICH TO RESPOND TO ENVIRONMENTAL
FACTORS. THIS INDIVIDUALITY ALLOWS US TO CLEAR NOXIOUS SUBSTANCES OR TO CONTRIBUTE
TO OUR OWN BODY BURDEN. BIOCHEMICAL INDIVIDUALITY DEPENDS ON AT LEAST THREE
FACTORS: GENETICS, THE STATE OF THE FETUS€™S NUTRITIONAL HEALTH AND TOXIC BODY
BURDEN DURING PREGNANCY, AND THE PERSON€™S TOXIC BODY BURDEN IN LATER LIFE IN
RELATION TO NUTRITIONAL STATE AT THE TIME OF EXPOSURE. FOR EXAMPLE, SOME PERSONS
ARE BORN WITH SIGNIFICANTLY LESS OF A SPECIFIC ENZYME. ALTHOUGH THAT PERSON MAY
BE ABLE TO RESPOND TO AN ENVIRONMENTAL STIMULANT, THIS RESPONSE IS OFTEN
CONSIDERABLY LESS THAN THAT OF THE PERSON WHO WAS BORN WITH 100% OF THE EXPECTED
DETOXIFYING ENZYME AND IMMUNE PARAMETERS.
ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION
RECENT STUDIES HAVE SHOWN THAT NEARLY HALF OF THE WORLD€™S POLLUTANTS ARE
GENERATED BY MAN,4 ACCENTUATING THE PROBLEM DESCRIBED BY RANDOLPH5 MORE THAT 30
YEARS AGO. LITERALLY THOUSANDS OF SYNTHETIC CHEMICAL PRODUCTS HERETOFORE
BELIEVED INNOCUOUS HAVE BEEN INCRIMINATED AS AGENTS OF HOMEOSTATIC DYSFUNCTION. WITH
THE FINDINGS THAT SENSITIVITIES OCCUR IN ASSOCIATION WITH PICOMOLAR QUANTITIES
OF CHEMICAL AGENTS HAS COME THE DISCOVERY THAT PROCEDURES SUCH AS SKIN PRICK
OR SCRATCH TESTS OFTEN FAIL TO DEMONSTRATE POSITIVE REACTIONS THAT ARE
CLINICALLY VERIFIABLE BY OTHER MEANS.
RECENT LITERATURE VERIFIES PREVIOUS FINDINGS REGARDING THE HARMFUL EFFECTS OF
CERTAIN CHEMICAL INCITANTS, SUCH AS FORMALDEHYDE, PHENOL, CHLORINE, AND
PETROLEUM ALCOHOL.6 COMMONLY ENCOUNTERED CHEMICALS, SUCH AS GLYCINE,
CHLORPHENOTHANE, TOLUENE, AND TURPENTINE, HAVE BEEN ASSOCIATED WITH THE TRIGGERING OF A
PLETHORA OF VASCULAR ALTERATIONS,7-9 AND SOME FAMILIAR METALS, AMONG THEM NICKEL,
COBALT, CHROMIUM, ALUMINUM, AND MERCURY, HAVE BEEN IMPLICATED.10 OTHER COMMON
ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMICAL INCITANTS INCLUDE XYLENE, BENZOYL PEROXIDE, CARBON
TETRACHLORIDE, SULFATES, AND ISOCYANATES.
WATER POLLUTION
MINERALS, TOXIC ORGANIC AND INORGANIC CHEMICALS, PARTICULATE MATTER, AND
RADIATION PLAY AN IMPORTANT ROLE AS PATHWAYS FOR CHEMICAL CONTAMINANTS ENTERING
THE HUMAN ORGANISM. THE INCIDENCE OF MANY CHRONIC DISEASES (CORONARY DISEASE,
HYPERTENSION, AND STROKE) IS ASSOCIATED WITH VARIOUS WATER CHARACTERISTICS,
INCLUDING PURITY, HARDNESS, AND SOFTNESS.11-13 PROTECTIVE AGENTS FOUND IN HARD
WATER ARE CALCIUM, MAGNESIUM, VANADIUM, LITHIUM, CHROMIUM, AND MANGANESE.
CERTAINLY, ONCE CARDIOVASCULAR PATHOLOGY IS INDUCED, WATERS WITH HIGH SODIUM
CONTENT MAY BE COUNTERPRODUCTIVE. SUSPECTED HARMFUL AGENTS INCLUDE CADMIUM,
LEAD, COPPER, AND ZINC, WHICH TEND TO BE FOUND IN HIGHER CONCENTRATIONS IN SOFT
WATER. NITRATES (FROM FERTILIZER) IN WATER POSE IMMEDIATE THREATS TO CHILDREN
UNDER THREE MONTHS OF AGE BECAUSE OF THE PRODUCTION OF METHEMOGLOBULIN. SULFUR
WILL BE A PROBLEM TO SOME PEOPLE.
CITY WATER TODAY CONTAINS FROM 100 TO 10,000 TIMES AS MANY SYNTHETIC
COMPOUNDS AS NATURAL SPRING WATER. EXAMPLES OF GROSS WATER CONTAMINATION INCLUDE TIMES