Re: comments on WICD Mobile DOM section

Hello public-cdf,

Anne wrote:

>> As part of CDRF "2.2.2 Event-Related
Markup" [1] it states that profiles
>> must define their mapping to DOM Level 3 Events. 
As SVG does already
>> provide this, it is important to highlight it.  We
will not be making any
>> changes based on this comment.
> 
> Highlight is not the same as making it normative.
Making the section  
> non-normative would satisfy my comment. If the group
for some reason wants  
> it normative I object to this descision since it seems
unwise to make  
> requirements twice.

The profile requires the mapping to DOM 3 events; WICD is
therefore
required to do so. It does it by pointing to the spec that
actually
defines this (rather than *re*defining it). I don't
understand the
objection.

-- 
 Chris Lilley                    mailto:chrisw3.org
 Interaction Domain Leader
 Co-Chair, W3C SVG Working Group
 W3C Graphics Activity Lead
 Co-Chair, W3C Hypertext CG

On Thu, 15 Mar 2007 00:23:10 +0100, Chris Lilley
<chrisw3.org> wrote:
>>> As part of CDRF "2.2.2 Event-Related
Markup" [1] it states that  
>>> profiles
>>> must define their mapping to DOM Level 3
Events.  As SVG does already
>>> provide this, it is important to highlight it. 
We will not be making  
>>> any
>>> changes based on this comment.
>>
>> Highlight is not the same as making it normative.
Making the section
>> non-normative would satisfy my comment. If the
group for some reason  
>> wants
>> it normative I object to this descision since it
seems unwise to make
>> requirements twice.
>
> The profile requires the mapping to DOM 3 events; WICD
is therefore
> required to do so. It does it by pointing to the spec
that actually
> defines this (rather than *re*defining it). I don't
understand the
> objection.

Hmm, this is about section 3.6.12. What I'm saying is that I
don't think  
that section should be normative as support for SVG is
already required  
elsewhere. However, looking at the section again I suppose
it's not such a  
major problem...


-- 
Anne van Kesteren
<http://annevankesteren
.nl/>
<http://www.opera.com/>