-----original message-----
From: filter-editor%40cyber.law.harvard.edu">filter-editor
cyber.law.harvard.edu < filter-editor%40cyber.law.harvard.edu">filter-editor
cyber.law.harvard.edu>
Date: Dec 22, 2006 4:11 PM
Subject: [the-filter] [The Filter] December 2006
To: the-filter%40eon.law.harvard.edu">the-filter
eon.law.harvard.edu
<-- The Filter --> December 2006
Your regular dose of public-interest Internet news and commentary from
the Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard Law School.
FILTER CONTENTS:
[0] From the Center
[1] Features
[2] Networked: Bookmarks, Webcasts, Podcasts, Tags, and Blogposts
[3] Global Voices: Digital Dose of Global Conversations
[4] Community Links
[5] Upcoming Conferences
[6] Staying Connected
[7] Filter Facts
[0] From the Center
===================================================================================================================
It's the end of the year for many of our readers, but around here the
year is at its half-way mark; lots of excitement is yet to come before
graduation time. Looking back, it's always hard to believe how much
has happened at the Center and around our community, but this year our
collective space has been nothing short of explosive. What may have
been deemed niche issues, are now firmly established as mainstream
concerns. Whether one considers the proliferation of blogs, podcasts
and other user-generated media (paired with traditional media's
increasing embrace of the Net); the novel ways governments, activists,
universities, and businesses are engaging with new technologies,
business models and partners; or the rapid pace and changing landscape
of technological innovation, it is clear that change is afoot. There
remains a long way to travel in so many senses, and we look forward to
watching – and participating – in this revolution with you. My sincere
thanks for your loyal readership and best wishes for the holiday
season.
-- Colin Maclay, Managing Director, Berkman Center--
[1] FEATURES: a bit of what's going on at Berkman and where to read more
===================================================================================================================
Folksonomy as Symbol
~David Weinberger
It's easy to minimize the importance of folksonomies. These bottom-up
taxonomies are just another tool in the kit. Besides, they've been
around for a while, well before Thomas Vander Wal gave them a
felicitous name. For example, at eBay a sellers' preference for
'laptop' over 'notebook' has emerged all by itself. In fact, isn't
language itself the first folksonomy? Words evolve based on bottom-up
usage. So, taxonomies are nothing new.
If that's so, then we're led ever more forcefully to ask: Why the
fuss? If folksonomies are old hat, why are we treating them like
something fresh and important?
Certainly, in part it's because folksonomies are particularly useful
when there are lots of people trying to communicate about a shared set
of resources and when there's no central authority that can stipulate
the accepted vocabulary and canonical taxonomy. The Web is just such
an environment. So, even though there have been folksonomies in the
past, the Web has given them a big, whopping, important problem to
solve. But, there are lots of innovations for dealing with the Web
that have not excited the same degree of enthusiasm. Listmania at
Amazon is new and interesting, but not spurring academic conferences.
Ebay's trust system is important, but is generally being taken as a
useful mechanism, not a change in how we think or how crowds operate.
Something about folksonomies has struck a chord, generating interest
beyond their benefits as navigational tools. Folksonomies seem to have
a symbolic value.
If a folksonomy is a symbol, what is it a symbol of?
First, folksonomies stick it to The Man. We don't need no stinkin'
experts to organize ideas and information! There is, of course,
inefficiency built into expert-based taxonomies because they have to
choose one way of ordering, and that one way is necessarily infested
with personal, class, and cultural biases. As Clay Shirky says,
"Metadata is worldview." But beyond the inefficiency, simply having
someone else have the authority to say 'It shall be filed thus' is a
statement of political authority. Even when the experts do a good
job—as they usually do, because they're experts—it is still an
implicit statement that someone else's way of thinking is better than
yours.
In the face of this, folksonomy says not just that we each have our
own way, but that something useful emerges from it. Folksonomies are
proof of the power of emergence. Emergence is a fascinating phenomenon
because it explains complexity through intrinsic simplicity. For
example, termites build complex towers by following rules so simple
that they fit in a termite's brain. But there is also a political side
to our interest in emergence, beyond its explanatory power. Emergence
is hope. It says (or we take it as saying) that left to ourselves,
without extrinsic structuring or regulation or governance, we will be
magnificent. This is beyond the hope implicit in democracy that says a
group will be able to live together if all are given equal power. We
won't just live together, but something far beyond the capabilities of
any of us will emerge. Simply by being together, cathedrals will
emerge...
The rest of Dr. Weinberger's essay can be found here:
<http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/home/home?wid=10&func=viewSubmission&sid=2541>
Technology in the Classroom
The great interest in Berkman Center Faculty Director Terry Fisher and
Berkman Fellow William McGeveran's paper, "The Digital Learning
Challenge: Obstacles to Educational Uses of Copyrighted Material in
the Digital Age," suggests that the question of technology's influence
in education is emerging in many fields and across disciplines.
Analyzing the ways in which educators are constrained by digital
copyright protections, the paper's ranking at the Social Science
Research Network (SSRN) sees it as a top download in four subject
areas: it is the #1 all-time download in "New Institutional
Economics", the #7 all-time download in "IO: Productivity, Innovation
& Technology", the #2 all-time download "PIT: Innovation