Dave,
I think charity badges like ChipIn are great, but they have a disadvantage vs. a centrally managed system (like Convio, Kintera, FirstGiving, Active Giving, Artez). With ChipIn, each participant must have a personal web page already (which could be a MySpace or FaceBook page). It's unlikely that someone who doesn't already have a web site or social networking page is going to create one just to participate in a charity event.
In addition, each participant must have the technical skills to install the widget. That's trivial for people like those on the ISF, but I know that many people are intimidated by such a task. I don't have statistics, but I know that many people never personalize their Convio/Kintera/FirstGiving/Active/Artez pages. But since they're managed centrally, these pages can still collect donations and credit them to the right participants.
Robert
__________________________
Robert L. Weiner Consulting
Strategic Technology Advisors to Nonprofit and Educational Institutions
San Francisco, CA
robert%40rlweiner.com">robert
rlweiner.com
415/643-8955
www.rlweiner.com
-----original message-----
>>The most elegant, decentralized, and flexible way to do this is a new kid on the block: Chipin...they've got a new project in the works for nonprofits (this might be out already) that allows person-to-person fundraising with live updates, via an extremely portable flash widget. This can be placed on MySpace, academic websites, community portals, Facebook pages, and pretty much anywhere else. I believe Facebook integration is particularly powerful. I'd check them out for more information. It shouldn't be too hard to tie the Chipin system with a Drupal + CiviCRM front end for more sophisticated tracking, and it would cost a lot less than a commercial package. Chipin is free + nominal credit card processing costs. Carnet, are you on this list? If so, let us know if Chipin for nonprofits is out and about >>