Re: kpowersave suspend-to-ram does not work - private mail

Modestas Vainius wrote:

> Sveiki,
> 
> 2007 m. July 24 d., Tuesday, jūs rašėte:
>> Powersave is not a kubuntu specific production.
>> Don't you think any readers of this mailing list
might have faced
>> troubles of that kind i have described?
> Works for me (Debian unstable amd64). You see, suspend
is very very
> kernel/configuration/distro sensitive due to various
ways to perform it.
> Methods, which work on one distro/configuration, might
not work on
> another. And who knows if ubuntu hasn't patched
kpowersave.
> 

As you surely know, that do not exclude troubles due to
conditions users can
produce by tinkering about their system (xorg
misconfiguration, acpi wrong
set up, etc). An help on this regard could be provided by
kubuntu or debian
users, as well. 
 
So what is the real reason you are rejecting access to a
user? Are you  
acting on behalf of a well representative group?

I am sure the debian people are more open than you would
say.

--
Pol


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-kde-REQUESTlists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact
listmasterlists.debian.org

HI,

2007 M. JULY 24 D., TUESDAY, POL RA??:
> AS YOU SURELY KNOW, THAT DO NOT EXCLUDE TROUBLES DUE TO
CONDITIONS USERS
> CAN PRODUCE BY TINKERING ABOUT THEIR SYSTEM (XORG
MISCONFIGURATION, ACPI
> WRONG SET UP, ETC). AN HELP ON THIS REGARD COULD BE
PROVIDED BY KUBUNTU OR
> DEBIAN USERS, AS WELL.
YES, ESPECIALLY, XORG VIDEO DRIVERS (PROPRIETARY FGLRX IS
ESPECIALLY BAD AT 
THIS) AND HARDWARE ETC. MAYBE KPOWERSAVE DOES NOT UNLOAD
KERNEL MODULES WHICH 
KLAPTOPDAEMON DOES? MY EXPERIENCE WITH KLAPTOPDAEMON IS
PRETTY CONTRATRY TO 
YOURS. THE LAST TIME (KDE 3.4 MAYBE) I TRIED IT OUT IT
DIDN'T WORK FOR ME IN 
MOST AREAS (INCL. SUSPEND) WHEREAS KPOWERSAVE DID.

> SO WHAT IS THE REAL REASON YOU ARE REJECTING ACCESS TO
A USER? ARE YOU
> ACTING ON BEHALF OF A WELL REPRESENTATIVE GROUP?
I'M NOT ACTING AS REPRESENTATIVE AND I'M NOT REJECTING
ANYTHING. I'M JUST 
SAYING THAT THERE ARE MANY DISTRO SPECIFIC FACTORS INVOLVED
SO IT'S THE BEST 
BET TO CONSULT DISTRO SPECIFIC FORUMS/MAILING LISTS. DON'T
MAKE IT PERSONAL.

-- 
MODESTAS VAINIUS <MODESTASVAINIUS.EU>

EL MARTES, 24 DE JULIO DE 2007, POL ESCRIBIó:
> AN HELP ON THIS REGARD COULD BE PROVIDED BY KUBUNTU OR
> DEBIAN USERS, AS WELL.

YES, AND RED HAT USERS TOO. WILL YOU BE SURPRISED IF YOU GOT
A SIMILAR 
RESPONSE IN A RED HAT MAILINGLIST?

I'M NOT VERY ACTIVE RIGHT NOW HELPING IN MAILING LISTS OR
BUG REPORTS, BUT I 
PROMISE THAT WHEN I WAS, SOMETIMES IT'S VERY COMPLEX TO
REPRODUCE A PROBLEM 
WITH A BIT BY BIT IDENTICAL PACKAGE. IF YOU USE A DIFFERENT
DISTRIBUTION ITS 
NOT A DIFFERENT LEAGUE, IT'S A DIFFERENT SPORT.

-- 
ALEX (A.K.A. SUY) - GPG ID 0X0B8B0BC2
HTTP://BARNACITY.NET/ - JABBER ID: SUYBULMALUG.NET