List Info

Thread: Re: Authenticity of Authoritative hCard (was: Re: Vote on this: rel="me self" to indi




Re: Authenticity of Authoritative hCard (was: Re: Vote on this: rel="me self" to indi
user name
2007-01-31 11:03:08
On 31 Jan 2007, at 15:50, Ara Pehlivanian wrote:
> Yes, but what if someone registers ben-ward.net and
puts up a fake
> card on that site. Then he goes and publishes a partial
hCard on
> myspace and points to ben-ward.net/about with
rel="self me". He's
> effectively hijacked your identity and/or caused
confusion and there's
> no real way to verify who's who or who's telling the
truth.

That's still no different to life without rel="me
self".

I happen to own the domains <ben-ward.co.uk> and
<ben-ward.com>. Note  
hyphens. I do not own <benward.com> ,
<benward.co.uk>  nor any other  
variant.

Domains do not prove identity. What I can do is make my
entire  
‘online identy’ parsable by linking between my domains and
my social  
network profiles using rel="me". That doesn't tell
you anything more  
about me as a person than the fact that
<flickr/photos/benward>, <ben- 
ward.co.uk> and <myspace.com/benwardcouk> are part
of the same  
personal network of sites.

The owner of Ben-Ward.net could have his own personal
network of  
sites too, but they would not be linked to from my own
authoritative  
hCard at ben-ward.co.uk/about. Nothing stops him add
rel="me" to his  
hcard pointing to my site, but that takes us well out of
scope of  
hcard, and is still a different issue — not something
introduced by  
rel="me self"

Ben
_______________________________________________
microformats-discuss mailing list
microformats-discussmicroformats.org
http://microformats.org/mailman/listinfo/microforma
ts-discuss

Re: Authenticity of Authoritative hCard (was: Re: Vote on this: rel="me self" to indi
user name
2007-01-31 11:14:50
On 31 Jan 2007, at 17:03, Ben Ward wrote:
> The owner of Ben-Ward.net could have his own personal
network of  
> sites too, but they would not be linked to from my own 

> authoritative hCard at ben-ward.co.uk/about. Nothing
stops him add  
> rel="me" to his hcard pointing to my site,
but that takes us well  
> out of scope of hcard, and is still a different issue —
not  
> something introduced by rel="me self"

Actually I'm wrong here. The XFN spec points out that rel=me
must be  
symmetric, so the owner of ben-ward.net could *not* validly
link to  
ben-ward.co.uk with rel=me unless I linked back likewise.

“me: A link to yourself at a different URL. Exclusive of all
other  
XFN values. *Required symmetric*.”

Ben
_______________________________________________
microformats-discuss mailing list
microformats-discussmicroformats.org
http://microformats.org/mailman/listinfo/microforma
ts-discuss

[1-2]

about | contact  Other archives ( Real Estate discussion Medical topics )