List Info

Thread: supported h/w raid controllers (SATA or IDE)




supported h/w raid controllers (SATA or IDE)
user name
2006-04-27 03:51:04

I'm trying to put together a half decent home server with
around 400-500 gig of disk space and some redundancy - I
can get 3 x 300GB IDA or SATA disks quite cheap, or 2 400GB
for
quite a bit more... So I think maybe HW RAID5. or raid-Z
if I have a change in tack and look at opensolaris or ZFS
gets
ported to NetBSD?  I don't want to take the performance hit
on
s/w RAID5, as I'm hoping to run this as a xen server at
some point
and want all the CPU I can get if and when I do that.  This
will be
going into a desktop style case and will not use SCSI (the
disks are
just way too expensive).  If I'm wrong and s/w RAID 5
doesn't suck (my
experience with s/w RAID5 was on an old Sun E450 with 3 x
36GB SCSI
disks running SunOS 5.8 and it was a -dog-) then I'm happy
to be
corrected for my false assumption!

Looking through the hardware support pages on the netbsd.org
site
there's a bundle of different controllers listed here :

http://www.ne
tbsd.org/Hardware/pci.html

But I don't know which of them is much good, so throw
myself
open to the wisdom of the list.  Any suggestions?  What's
good
and cheap (I know ...) and easy to get hold of?

Thanks!

Carl

supported h/w raid controllers (SATA or IDE)
user name
2006-04-27 04:17:06
Carl Brewer wrote:
> 
> 
> I'm trying to put together a half decent home server
with
> around 400-500 gig of disk space and some redundancy -
I
> can get 3 x 300GB IDA or SATA disks quite cheap, or 2
400GB for
> quite a bit more... So I think maybe HW RAID5. or
raid-Z
> if I have a change in tack and look at opensolaris or
ZFS gets
> ported to NetBSD?  I don't want to take the
performance hit on
> s/w RAID5, as I'm hoping to run this as a xen server
at some point
> and want all the CPU I can get if and when I do that. 
This will be
> going into a desktop style case and will not use SCSI
(the disks are
> just way too expensive).  If I'm wrong and s/w RAID 5
doesn't suck (my
> experience with s/w RAID5 was on an old Sun E450 with 3
x 36GB SCSI
> disks running SunOS 5.8 and it was a -dog-) then I'm
happy to be
> corrected for my false assumption!
> 
> Looking through the hardware support pages on the
netbsd.org site
> there's a bundle of different controllers listed here
:
> 
> http://www.ne
tbsd.org/Hardware/pci.html
> 
> But I don't know which of them is much good, so throw
myself
> open to the wisdom of the list.  Any suggestions? 
What's good
> and cheap (I know ...) and easy to get hold of?

Further to this, I can get the Adaptec 2410SA at an
affordable
price (it's around $500 AUD - roughly the cost of a 400GB
HDD).
With that in mind, I'm leaning more towards a RAID1 setup
instead as I guess the extra cost for the controller gets
rid of
the cost difference (not to mention the extra power
consumption from
3 disks, heat, noise etc).

Am I crazy?

[1-2]

about | contact  Other archives ( Real Estate discussion Medical topics )